Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Success! Now Check Your Email

To complete Subscribe, click the confirmation link in your inbox. If it doesn’t arrive within 3 minutes, check your spam folder.

Ok, Thanks

Slovak Federation Leaders Spark Another Clubs Backlash With Plans To Increase Powers

The crisis in Slovakian swimming, now subject to scrutiny at the Aquatics Integrity Unit, will surge once more tomorrow, when a federation conference considers proposals to add constitutional powers over clubs that critics say had already been cited as grounds for suspending clubs months ago

Craig Lord profile image
by Craig Lord
Slovak Federation Leaders Spark Another Clubs Backlash With Plans To Increase Powers
Ragout of how the Plavecká platforma has highlighted its objections to the proposals that have appeared on the SPF website during the past fortnight

Proposals criticised as "a retrospective power grab" by Slovakian Swimming Federation bosses will be considered at the SPF's Conference tomorrow, November 20, sparking more controversy in a schism in the sport that is already under scrutiny at the global Aquatics Integrity Unit.

In the wake of extensive coverage of the crisis in the Slovakian media, SOS revealed that some of the members of almost half the nation's swimming clubs that were suspended by federation leaders back in the summer had submitted a complaint against the SPF leadership to European integrity authorities. That was then handed to the AQIU, which has begun investigations:

Slovak Swim Boss Šulek Faces Integrity Probe That Will Test Aquatics Reporting Systems
Red flags fly over troubled waters. What happens when a federation & its president shut down almost half of a nation's swim clubs, athletes are told their races won't be recognised, over a million euros in public funding is lost in the wash and those reporting concerns are suspended?

In the midst of those, the SPF leadership has made moves to reinstate some clubs under specific conditions, while others remain suspended. The latter are barred from attending the conference tomorrow and therefore will have no chance to voice their opposition nor vote on measures that would allow the SPF to exercise more power over clubs than it had at the time of the suspensions.

Opposition clubs claim that they were suspended on false grounds because the SPF did not have the powers it is now seeking through proposals on the table tomorrow.

The proposals at the heart of the controversy are as follows, according to announcements posted on the SPF website in the past few weeks:

1. Proposed Amendment No. 6, point 7 — introducing a new Article 16(7):

„Ak sa riadny člen SPF v kalendárnom roku viac ako dvakrát nezúčastní na riadnej alebo opakovanej Konferencii, výkonný orgán SPF môže rozhodnúť o pozastavení jeho členstva.“

English translation: “If an ordinary member of SPF fails to attend an ordinary or repeated Conference more than twice in a calendar year, SPF’s executive body may decide to suspend its membership.”

2. Proposed Amendment No. 6, point 16:

„V článku 23 ods. 2 sa vypúšťajú slová ‚s výnimkou písm. g)‘.“

“In Article 23(2), the words ‘with the exception of point (g)’ are deleted.”

Point (g) is an obligation to attend the Conference. 
 
3. Explanatory memorandum — section 6 in full, in the Slovak original:

6. Neúčasť na Konferencii
Čo sa mení
Ak sa riadny člen v kalendárnom roku viac ako dvakrát nezúčastní riadnej alebo opakovanej Konferencie, Rada môže pozastaviť jeho členstvo.
Povinnosť zúčastňovať sa Konferencie sa stáva vymáhateľnou aj disciplinárne. Doteraz bola z disciplinárnej zodpovednosti výslovne vyňatá.
Prečo
Účasť na Konferencii je povinnosťou každého člena. Neúčasť spôsobuje, že Konferencia nie je uznášaniaschopná a SPF nemôže prijímať potrebné rozhodnutia. Doteraz neúčasť nemala žiadny následok.

English:  6. Non-attendance at the Conference

What changes
If an ordinary member fails to attend an ordinary or repeated Conference more than twice in a calendar year, the Council may suspend its membership.
The obligation to attend the Conference becomes enforceable through disciplinary proceedings as well. Until now, it was expressly excluded from disciplinary liability.

Why
Attendance at the Conference is an obligation of every member. Non-attendance prevents the Conference from having a quorum and SPF from adopting necessary decisions. Until now, non-attendance had no consequence.


Some of those proposals are the subject of considerable head-scratching in the Slovakian swimming community. Slovakian media coverage of the crisis and the moves that led to the AQIU submission and start of inquiries, cited SPF leadership figures as stating that one of the key reasons for suspending clubs back in July was their 'failure' to attend meetings and thus hold up the business of the federation. 

Yet now, it would appear, the SPF is seeking to add new provisions to the constitution which grant leaders the power they claimed they already had, according to sources in the opposition camp. One told SOS:

"If they [SPF leaders] claim that their actions were already permitted under the statutes in force back in July, why do they now feel the need to change them and insert new provisions? That speaks volumes, even to outside observer, like you in the media. They have some serious questions to answer."

SOS contacted the Slovakian Swimming Federation and its president Ivan Šulek for comment last weekend. Answers have been pledged but not until after November 23 on the grounds that the workload of the Slovak Swimming Federation and its preparations for the SPF Conference tomorrow meant they were "unable to respond within the timeframe" proposed. Our request was for answers by the close of the business day on Wednesday. SOS will publish any SPF responses to our questions when or should we receive any.

One of the burning questions is this: is it appropriate to hold a vote on proposals at the heart of a crisis at a time when the matter is subject to an integrity inquiry process and those members of the Slovak swimming community who disagree with the federation leadership are barred from having a say through a suspension that is a core part of the whole dispute?

Meanwhile, AQIU is understood to have powers to prevent action against witnesses and those reporting concerns at times of dispute. It remains to be seen if they exercise any such power in a sport.

The Integrity regime is in its infancy, but World Aquatics is familiar with federation and national disputes. It has intervened in numerous arguments, including one in which nothing was remotely close to involving the suspension of half a nation's clubs, but in which Swimming Australia found itself threatened by action that might have extended to whole-nation suspension.

Such issues are among reasons why leading figures in swimming have suggested that the whole "reform" and even "integrity" process needs itself to be scrutinised.

The Slovakian conference and its proposals are the subject of domestic Slovakian reports, such as this at aktuality.sk:

Slovenskú plaveckú federáciu (SPF) čaká v piatok 20. novembra 2026 dôležité rokovanie Konferencie SPF v Bratislave, na ktorej sa bude rozhodovať o zásadných zmenách vnútorných pravidiel fungovania zväzu | Aktuality.sk
Hoci vedenie federácie koncom októbra zrušilo pozastavenie členstva väčšine pôvodne suspendovaných (64) klubov, napätie v slovenskom plávaní pred blížiacim sa hlasovaním pretrváva. Piatkové dianie na konferencii ovplyvnia najmä tieto kľúčové okolnosti: 1. Zmena stanov a upevnenie pozície vedenia federácie: Na programe rokovania je schvaľovanie Dodatku č. 6 k Stanovám SPF. Podľa kritikov z radov klubov tieto úpravy posilňujú právomoci Rady SPF na úkor členskej základne – napríklad rozšírením vplyvu Rady na podmienky zachovania členstva, možnosťou preraďovať kluby do kategórií s obmedzenými právami, zakotvením postihov za neúčasť na konferenciách a sťažením podmienok na zvolanie mimoriadnej konferencie zo strany členov. 2. Rozštiepená a neistá pozícia 60 klubov: Približne šesťdesiat klubov vstupuje do rokovania v dvoch rozdielnych postaveniach. Desať klubov má naďalej pozastavené členstvo, a teda nemôže vykonávať svoje práva a vedenie zväzu ich na piatkovú konferenciu ani nepozvalo. Ďalším zhruba päťdesiatim klubom síce federácia členské práva formálne obnovila, ale disciplinárne konania voči nim pre tie isté skutky naďalej pokračujú a podľa schválených podmienok im môže byť členstvo kedykoľvek opätovne pozastavené. Celé dianie okolo postupov vedenia SPF a prezidenta federácie Ivana Šuleka má aj medzinárodnú dohru. Podľa informácií redakcie Aktuality.sk sa viacerých podnetom slovenských plaveckých klubov aktívne venuje Jednotka pre integritu vodných športov (AQIU), ktorá už vedenie SPF opakovane vyzvala na zaujatie oficiálneho stanoviska.

Opposition To The Proposals

Concerned member of the Slovakian swimming community launched their own Facebook page in June to raise awareness of the issues in play.

The Plavecká platforma ("Swimming Platform"), a dedicated community and informational page for swimming in Slovakia, launched with the purpose of acting as a space for civil, fact-based discussion in the sport, has criticised the proposals on the table at a meeting tomorrow.

Under a banner headline "THE FEDERATION BELONGS TO THE CLUBS. THE MANAGEMENT SHOULD BE ACCOUNTABLE TO THEM", the platform provides its opinion and its interpretation of the proposals.

On Amendment No. 6 to the SPF Statutes, it states:

"With this proposal, the management is asking for additional power over the clubs and over the decisions of their highest body. The experience of recent months shows why we need stronger management control, transparency and accountability for decisions. The proposal weakens the tools with which clubs can exercise this control. The direction of the federation and its money should be decided primarily by the clubs through the Conference. The functions are a mandate for the management of the joint federation. They do not entitle the management to appropriate additional powers at the expense of the members."

Among other concerns and questions they raise are the following:

  • "CLUBS APPROVE THE BUDGET. THE MANAGEMENT SHOULD BE ABLE TO CHANGE IT SUBSEQUENTLY".
"The proposal will allow the Council to approve individual budget changes of up to €50,000 and the President up to €10,000. The Conference will learn about the approved changes subsequently. The text lacks a common annual limit and the rule for adding related changes. The budget is one of the most important decisions of the Conference. It determines the priorities of the federation and the use of common money. The clubs are to decide what the funds will be used for — and the management is to be given the authority to change this decision to the specified extent without their new consent. This weakens the very meaning of the clubs' vote on the SPF's finances."
  • THE COUNCIL IS TO DETERMINE WHICH CLUBS WILL RETAIN A FULL VOTE.
"It will set the criteria for regular membership. A reassigned club will lose its vote on most decisions, including the budget, management reports, or the dismissal of the president and members of the Council."

You can see the full critique at the Swimming Platform:


Craig Lord profile image
by Craig Lord

Become an SOS+ Reader

For details of free sign-up and subscription packages, click on the floating subscribe button

Success! Now Check Your Email

To complete Subscribe, click the confirmation link in your inbox. If it doesn’t arrive within 3 minutes, check your spam folder.

Ok, Thanks

Read More